Object with Neutral Gender

illustration

The object that came to mind when I thought of a gender neutral object was a tube of toothpaste.

Of all of the products that we use for personal care, most of them have a gender associated with them. Some products are conventionally thought of as only being used by one gender, such as cologne for men or makeup for women. There are many other products that both genders typically use, but these products still are sold as different varieties for men and women. For example, products such as soap, shaving cream, or deodorant are all sold in male and female varieties, which typically have different packaging, colors, and scents. One of the only examples of these products that I could think of that doesn’t seem to have a gender identity is toothpaste. I’ve never seen any men’s or women’s toothpaste.

After watching the video, I thought about the things that I use to make assumptions about gender. Often, these assumptions are simply based on appearance, such as what clothes someone wears or what their hair looks like. Just like any stereotypes, these observations may be true for some people, but don’t fit for many others. There are so many people who don’t follow these gender stereotypes that it is extremely unproductive to make these visual assumptions, yet I think most people still do. I think it is something so ingrained in our culture that it is hard to get rid of.

The Navajo culture mentioned in the video, who differentiate between the gender a person is born with and the role they play in life, have had their own view of gender, and just like us it has been ingrained in them for so long that it would likely be hard for them to see gender any other way either. I think there has been some progress recently in our culture in being more accepting of uniqueness in people in a variety of aspects, although there is a long way to go to transform the typical stereotypes into something like the Navajo people have or any other mindset.

When I see someone who does not seem obviously male or female, it may instinctively confuse me for a moment. Ultimately though, when I think about it, I recognize that the binary identification of gender doesn’t need to matter to someone’s identity.

Looking back at the toothpaste to see if there are any gender associations that could have been missed, I thought about the blue color and the mint flavoring, and tried to think about whether those features could give some kind of gender connotation. But at the end of the day, I feel like trying to find a gender identity in an item is just perpetuating stereotypes that don’t need to be continued anyway.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Object with Neutral Gender

  1. I agree that toothpaste is pretty gender neutral. It’s always funny to me to see packaging that declares two products that are essentially the same, different because one is for women and one is for men. But I haven’t seen that done with toothpaste yet. I believe this is because it’s a pretty basic product – there is no scent that can be “girly” or “masculine” and its use isn’t dependent on gender, either.

    I also really like your statement, “I feel like trying to find a gender identity in an item is just perpetuating stereotypes that don’t need to be continued anyway.” People like to “beat a dead horse” for lack of a better term and try to read more into a situation than is needed. If a girl wants to do boyish things or a boy wants to do girlish things, they should be able to without needed to analyze and determine what gender they are, or even what things are “boyish” or “girlish”. Just do what you enjoy and own it, regardless of the stereotype. Yes, gender can be non-binary, but I also think it’s overly-complicated. What gender you are shouldn’t determine your life.

  2. What is important to understand is that there are exceptions to the concept of gender targeting. When it comes to consumer products, there is often more money to be made by selling a product to a particular gender as opposed to both males and females.

    This is not the case when it comes to toothpaste as the post above attests to. Crest’s choice of colors could be construed as being unbiased, but to me there is no conscious effort being made to label this product as more appropriate for a particular gender.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s